Make This: S’mores Ice Cream Sandwich

By Brittni • Updated on 01/29/2024

A s’mores ice cream sandwich too yummy to resist!

S'more Ice Cream Sandwich Recipe

So apparently, I missed the boat on national s’more day over the weekend, but I’m not letting that stop me from posting today’s DIY.

It’s still summer and I can s’more if I want to.

So…I made these little s’more ice cream sandwiches to channel my inner summer camp kid, while simultaneously appeasing my adult self. Plus, it’s too hot outside not have something cold to go with that warm toasted marshmallow and melty chocolate. Want to make your own?

Ice Cream Sandwich S'mores


  • graham crackers
  • your favorite ice cream
  • marshmallows (I used the jumbo kind from the grocery store)
  • chocolate (milk, dark, or white)

How to Make a S’mores Ice Cream Sandwich

I know you don’t need a tutorial for s’mores. But I’ll just share how I made mine anyway. Wouldn’t be a DIY without instructions, right? 

Toast the marshmallows over a flame (campfire or a creme brûlée torch) to make them warm and a little bit melty.

Put a piece of chocolate onto a graham cracker, add the marshmallow on top, and set aside.

Then put a large scoop of ice cream onto a second graham cracker. And put the first cracker onto the second to create a sandwich.

These are a fun treat for a backyard dinner party with friends or even a kid’s birthday party.

But let’s be real. Anytime toasted marshmallows are involved, I’m game. Regardless of the occasion.

What about you though? Think you’ll give these a try?

S'more Ice Cream Sandwiches

More Ice Cream Sandwich Ideas

S'more + Ice Cream Sandwich

S'more Ice Cream Sandwich

Concept, photography, and styling by Brittni Mehlhoff

Want more ice cream sandwich ideas? Head over here.

28 comments | Click here to reply

[…] of s’more recipes over the years – mini s’more pizzas, s’more pop tarts, s’more ice cream sandwiches – but nothing quite like this one…Because these s’mores are in a cup! Plus, […]

S'more Please: Make-Ahead Summer S'more Cups Recipe

[…] S’mores ice cream sandwiches […]

Savoring Summer #2: Twists on ice cream - So About What I Said

[…] 1. (above) s'more ice cream sandwiches […]

6 Ice Cream Sandwiches for Your Sunday - Paper and StitchPaper and Stitch

It’s look delicious! 🙂


Ok you could not have taken better photo’s than these, this is beautiful! Omg cravings right now! Lol x

Black and Navy on the blog-


[…] 5.S’mores Ice Cream Sandwiches I’m so ready for summer. If this list is any indication, I’d say my brain is already in mid-July while my body is stuck in March. […]

New Series: Friday Favorites | Girl, Procrastinating

Amazing. Beatiful colours. Do you have any food styling tips to share 🙂

Brendon The Smiling Chef

[…] from top to bottom: pie, s’more, square waffle, variety sampler, round waffle, and […]

Trending: Ice Cream Sandwich » Continental Catering

[…] include any s’more ideas in this post, but I still have you covered in that department…ice cream sandwich s’mores and 7 ways to make s’mores even more […]

3 Delicious Ways to Celebrate National Toasted Marshmallow Day | Paper and Stitch

[…] 1. s’more ice cream sandwich recipe […]

6 DIYs to Try This Weekend | Paper and Stitch

[…] last week’s s’more ice cream sandwiches, I had a handful of additional ideas that I wanted to […]

Make This: 7 DIY Ways to Make S’mores Even More Delicious | Paper and Stitch

[…] Via Stripes / S’mores / Cooler / Bikini / Interior / Fitness / Peaches / […]

Pinterest Picks — Volume 1 | Evann Clingan

This looks like the best summer treat so far! I’m defiantly going to give these a try!


Yum!!! I had no clue it was smores day this past weekend. Oooh this would be amazing using the americone dream ice cream. Looks messy though 🙂


Ohhhh, these look SO GOOD! And I wish I’d seen this last night when my 3 year old asked for s’mores for her after-dinner treat.

Definitely stashing this in the dessert idea reserve! YUM.

Kelsey, Esp.

Funny that you mention that Marlen. Because I actually tested that…and you’re right. They taste like gas. It’s weird.

Which is why I recommend either a campfire or those little creme brûlée torches. Those things are handy!


yuuuuum, what sort of ice cream is that? it looks so darn pretty! and disclaimer all: don’t roast marshmallows with a gas stove flame. haha they taste a little….off =P

xo marlen
Messages on a Napkin


Right? It totally snuck right by me too.


How did I miss national s’mores day?! I’m definitely having a bonfire tomorrow.. and enough s’mores to make up for the loss.


Haha. Thanks ladies.




The Accidental Mama

The Accidental Mama

Thanks Arielle. This would be a perfect bonfire dessert.


ummm, you’re a genius! why didn’t I think of this? definitely pinning this for our next bonfire.

love, arielle
a simple elegance


Thanks Beth. Definitely give it a try.


hey hey hey!! This is an amazing idea. Ice cream on s’mores is something I’m more than willing to try RIGHT away! Kudos to you. xx


They’re pretty delicious. By the way, I just tried Reese’s on s’mores the other day and it was so good. Haven’t tried oreros though.


We’ve put many things on s’mores, peanut butter , Reeses, Oreos, etc., but never ice cream! This looks like it trumps them all!

Danielle @ Chits and Chats and Chocolate
Leave a reply